|

[from Paris]An overview of the Yellow Vests Crisis in France

I really like Paris during springtime. Weather is much better than during winter. The sky is blue, at least one day out of two, and cafés and bistros are full of tourists. I believe it’s the best season for visiting the Eiffel Tower, and for sipping a double espresso at the Trocadero square or walking at the Saint Germain des Près square, at the same place as Oscar Hemingway in the past.

Just like every Saturday morning, I waked up at about nine o’clock. I bought some croissants, I filled a big glass with fresh orange juice. Then? I turned on the TV, and I said:

“Oh no, it’s not true! There they go again!”.

It was just like in a living nightmare. The Champs Elysée avenue in Paris was on fire! A famous restaurant was damaged. A kiosk I know well was burning, and thick smoke was coming from a bank agency. Protestors wearing hoods were throwing stones at the police forces and they looted luxury shops. Two policemen behaved like true heroes saving a mom and her baby from the fire, just before the arrival of the firemen.

For one more time, since November 2018, the most beautiful avenue in the world had become a real battlefield, for a few hours! I was so upset that I switched the TV channel. I could not support any more seeing of what was happening. Enough is enough. Even though I am observing French politics for the last eighteen years, and I know that demonstrations are a big classic in France. French like to protest about almost everything. It’s cultural. It’s a part of their civilization, history and politics. Thousands of demonstrations take place every year in this country, and there are many reasons about that.

credit:AFP.

But why on March 16, 2019 all that happened?

The first reason could be the French method of negotiating. Unlike countries like Finland or Denmark, where negotiations about all maters take place in a very consensual manner, the French negotiations’ main characteristic is that there is no true dialogue! In every negotiation the two parts arrive not for really discussing, but for imposing their own point of view to the other without any concession. In this point, we should never forget that one of France’s sports symbols is the rooster. Which is a bird with a very strong personality, quite often spoiling for a fight. So French, since 1789, demonstrate. Just like during the famous May 1968 students’ movement, which affected dramatically the French society for the last four decades. Changing the shape of elite system and bringing on power the generation born after WWII. Of course, the situation is changing. More and more negotiations in France are now based on mutual understanding and on a more consensual approach. Even though, according to a very commonly used French stereotype, dialogue means nothing. It’s useless.

The second reason could be linked with the commonly known idea that the only thing that counts is pressure, through demonstrations and strikes in order to achieve a specific goal. This could also partially explain why violence is quite often used.  “If there is no violence, they will not listen to us” is the main argument used for justifying what is happening. Many French people are convinced that their elites don’t care about them, and they don’t have the same priorities. I think that this feeling derives from two different origins. On the one hand, from the longstanding French egalitarian and fraternity tradition. Never forget that in all public buildings are written the words “liberty-equality-fraternity” (Liberté-égalité-fraternité, in French). French like equality, and this is the reason why there is a very efficient public health system, and tuition fees for University studies are very low in comparison with other countries like in the UK, or in the USA. And, on the other hand, from the utopian spirit of the perfectly egalitarian society of the Paris Commune of 1871. Idealism is something quite noble. But coming back to reality, seems a quite complicated matter. Especially after the 2008 subprime crisis.      

The third reason could concern the civil disobedience, which is situated in the core of the French Republic. Unlike other countries where there is a top-down approach about power, in France, there is bottom-up one. After all, French people are not politized the same way as in other countries. They don’t like being members of political parties. They prefer to do politics through NGOs or by themselves by demonstrating. Putting into question the legitimacy of their leaders, and of their institutions almost every day! In some cases, I even find them very severe with their own elites. Unfortunately, some of them think that everything could be done by snapping the finger!  This could also explain why the last two French presidents, Nicolas Sarkozy in 2012, and François Hollande, in 2017 were not reelected. And why Emmanuel Macron is heavily criticized day and night about almost everything. A logical explanation about this could be how the French people show to their leaders that they hold the real power (since king’s Louis XVI decapitation, on 1793). Never forget, that since 1962, and the first election of the French president by elections, he is commonly called “the republican monarch”. Of course, he is one of the most powerful leaders in the world, but he always relies on the approval of his voters.

The fourth reason could be the so-called social fracture(s). It is based on the idea that there are two different France. Reminding the social class struggle, and a Marxist interpretation of social evolution. According to this point of view, the upper class has not the same interest as the lower class, and blue collars. Politicians are considered as too technocratic and disconnected from ordinary people priorities. In addition, a new division emerged within the last decades in France. A geographical one, between the wealthy owners living in down-town chic neighborhoods, and all these living in the countryside. What was presented as the crisis of the “peripheric France” (la France péripherique, in French). Schools and post offices close one after the other, as well as public administration services and bank agencies. Public transports’ organization does not correspond any more to today’s world reality and even internet connexon is not so efficient. All this gives the impression that the state abandons all these territories. The massive use of traffic monitoring radars, the reduction of the speed limit in local streets from 90 Km to 80Km per hour, as well as the rise of the gasoline price made many French people angry and fueled the rise of the Yellow Vests’ rallies all over the country, and especially in Paris.

The fifth reason could be the generalized use of fake news. I think that the yellow vest crisis is the first one in the XXIe century in France in which conspiracy theories played a key role. Social media and web sites are full of fake news and in this case, reality seems far beyond fiction. I had a lot of fun when I read that Emmanuel Macron is not a real person, but a “clone”! Or that he betrayed his own country; or that a Belgian Yellow Vest protestor died during a demonstration in Paris etc. etc. Of course, the freedom of press, and speech are fully protected by the French laws. But this is the first time in contemporary history that fake news is so much used by a political movement, for gaining support and legitimacy. What happened already has raised a lot of questions about publishing fake news. Many communication experts and journalists are really worrying about that, because, it could even put democracy into danger, within the years to come.  And the law voted on October 10, 2018 against fake news during elections, does not seem to be as efficient as it should. At least, for the time being.

The sixth reason could be the fact that there are less and less protestors participating in the Yellow Vests demonstrations every Saturday. They were 287.000 in the first one on November 2018 to more less 32.000 after 19 demonstrations, on March 16, 2019. Theoretically speaking, this seems quite obvious. Protestors are tired. They also failed into converting their movement into a political party. Like the Five Star movement in Italy, for example. According to the first polls a Yellow Vests party could obtain almost 13%, but according to the last one just 2%. Internal disputes, and rivalries did not allow the appearance of one or more charismatic personalities and revealed a big leadership problem. But, in my opinion, even worse, the Yellow Vest’s movement main problem is that it is not only one movement, but many, having completely different priorities, goals and ideological backgrounds. There are Yellow Vests looking for the improvement of purchasing power of blue-collar workers. There are Yellow Vests whose aim is to raise more taxes for the rich. There are Yellow Vests who asked a general of the French Army to take the power…etc. etc. As a result, it was just a matter of time for the whole situation to change dramatically.

The seventh reason could be linked to Emmanuel Macron’s reaction to the Yellow Vests crisis. Just like Jacques Chirac or Nicolas Sarkozy before him, Macron faced a big social movement. But, unlike Sarkozy or Holland, he reacted in a completed different way that looks quite surprising.

paris.

Emmanuel Macron participated in many debates all over France and spending many hours in each one. Such as the seven hours debate with 600 Normand mayors, which took place at the Grand Bourgtheroulde (population: 3,700), on January 15, 2019; the seven hours debate with 600 mayors at Souillac (population: 3,750), situated at the South West France (Occitanie) on January 18, 2019; the debate with local authorities at Bourg-de-Péage (population: 10.500) near Lyon, on January 24, 2019; the six hours debate with local authorities and NGOs at Courcouronnes (population:70,000), a popular suburb situated in the South of Paris. On February 7, 2019 he met 1000 young French between 15 and 25 years old at Morvan near Dijon. On March 1st he participated in a debate at Bordeaux, with local mayors, and in the afternoon in another debate with 400 women for celebrating the Woman’s day. On February 14, he participated in a debate at Gargiless-Dampierre (population: 300) a small rural village situated in Central France. By doing that, he managed to neutralize one of the Yellow Vests main arguments. Presenting him as a technocrat, who does not communicate with his voters.  

In the same time, he organized a Great Debate through a web site, and local meetings in which French people could put their complains in writing, in a book in every City Hall all over the country. This turned out be a big success. More than 1.8 million people participated until the last day, March 15, 2019. All manuscripts were scanned, and they were sent to the French National Library (BnF). All these meetings revealed a real interest from ordinary citizens and contributed in giving more legitimacy to the French president.

Finally, the eighth reason was in, my opinion, the Paris climate rally of March 16, 2010. More than 50,000 people, especially very young participated and there was not any violent incident. This could be the coup de grace for the Yellow Vest movement. Because, after all, there were much less Yellow Vest protestors. But also, because the Climate rally confirmed that the long-standing tradition of demonstrations will continue in Paris, but without the Yellow Vests. And above all, cafés, bistros and magazines owners seem to be furious with the Yellow Vest.

Even if everybody is looking forward for Emmanuel Macron’s response to the Grand Debate, it seems, that, at least in short term, he managed to cope with the Yellow Vest crisis. His popularity raised dramatically between December 2018 and January 2019. It seems that he managed to seduce again the middle-class electorate and to dominate again the French political parties’ system. Looking as a much better choice, both against the far-right Marine Le Pen and the conservative Laurent Wauquiez. Even though polls show that the situation could be quite complicated in the European parliament elections, in a few months.

But in the short term, an in-depth analysis about the Yellow Vests crisis, could raise the two following questions:

Was the Yellow Vests crisis inevitable?

According to Emmanuel Macron yes it was. It was the result of “a collective failure”. I fully understand his opinion. He considers that his business-friendly policies need some time in order to give results. But French voters were so disappointed by his predecessors, and so keen for a new way of doing politics, that they should be a little bit patient. Personally speaking, I am not convinced that this is so easy to do that because I see a lot of frustration around me. However, Macron managed to earn some time. Now, everything relies on the efficiency of his new measures after the end of the Grande Debate.

When the Yellow Vests crisis will end?

This is the one-million-dollar question. For me, everything relies on only one person. Emmanuel Macron. He declared once that he is the master of the clocks. It’s high time for him to prove it. If yes, he could be reelected for a second mandate on 2022. If not, he could do only one presidential mandate just like Nicolas Sarkozy and François Hollande before him.  

But, one way or another, French politics are always so unpredictable. So, let’s just wait for the weekend to come in order to see what will happen.

사이언스모니터 뉴스레터
AI·양자·R&D 핵심 해설을 주 2회(화·금) 이메일로 받아 보세요.

Similar Posts

답글 남기기